More discussion on charging your tithe

On last week's post on whether you should be able to put your tithe on a credit card, I received a well thought-out response from commenter Brian.  I'll reprint it here, and discuss it.

I work with more than 800 mainline protestant churches in Ohio. I say the credit card issue reflects larger issues in the church: The world is not the same that it was in the 50’s. Churches that do not recognize this will die.

This is seen in changes in music styles, less formal relationships with clergy, more short-term committee assignments and the way organizations of church women operate.

If we are to be relevant in our world and reach out to people, we have to be willing to do so on their terms and this includes finances. By allowing our “customers” to pay their pledges the same way they pay many other expenses, we are saying to them that we recognize we’re not in the 50’s anymore.

What is the good of churches allowing nontraditional giving methods?

1. Fewer people carry cash or check books with them at all times.
2. Regular on-line transfers help even out giving over the year. We know that if you don’t plop it in the pew you won’t put it in the plate, so giving traditionally dips in the summer time, during bad weather and on holiday weekends.
3. Electronic transfer allows greater privacy in giving. If I write a check and put it in the plate, volunteer counters and others may see what I give. But a concise electronic statement would only be seen by the Financial Secretary who would actually record my pledge.
4. Cash and checks have to be handled. They have to be counted, counted again, prepared for deposit and driven to the bank. In an era where volunteer time is harder to come by, let’s let our volunteers focus on doing the work of the kingdom and not tie them up counting money.
5. Cash is also a safety liability. Although this is quite rare, a pile of cash can be misappropriated, and with no cash register receipt to balance against, such a theft would go unnoticed.

I believe there are many positives to churches accepting credit cards, electronic funds transfers and other “modern” ways of conducting business.

Like I said, very well-thought-out comments.  Thank you!

My original post discussed the downside of tithing with a credit card, focusing mainly on the possibility of leading congregants into financial temptation and retarding spiritual growth, while not really discussing directly the advantages that such transactions can bring to churches.  Brian lists out some of these advantages, and I agree that many congregants would appreciate the fact that giving in this way was an option.

Like anything a church does to make itself more relevant, it should do so while holding true to biblical principles. And if I would be in a church that was considering this change, and if the leadership of the church made the decision to accept credit cards after faithful prayer and with the guidance of the Holy Spirit, I really wouldn't argue.  For example, if the church made training available from Financial Peace University, Crown Ministries, or some other Christian financial ministry, then that would give the opportunity to soften congregants' hearts in order to examine their giving in the context of this new technology.

If a church doesn't seek guidance from the Holy Spirit with regard to this, and does it for, perhaps, worldly reasons (“We need more regular giving” or “We need to encourage more giving”) then that's where problems are more likely to crop up.  That was the context of my original post.

I do disagree on one point within item #4.  I have helped with counting the offering for quite some time, and this is the work of the kingdom just as much as taking a missions trip to Africa.  I've learned a lot doing this, and I have no doubt that performing this task has helped me to grow spiritually.  Besides, even if credit cards come to the offering plate, checks and cash won't go away, and counting up the offering will still need to be done.  From my experience, counting up 50 checks doesn't take that much more time than counting up 15 checks, because of all the other set-up and tear-down work that's needed.

Anyway, any more thoughts on this? I'll be happy to write about it again next week.